My Great Grandpa Voted for Teddy Roosevelt

Roosevelt and Reed Smoot in Ogden, Utah

Roosevelt and Reed Smoot in Ogden, Utah

Unlike politicians today, Theodore Roosevelt told the American people what he thought.  Here are a few of my favorite Theodore Roosevelt quotes:

Behind the ostensible government sits enthroned an invisible government owing no allegiance and acknowledging no responsibility to the people–Theodore Roosevelt.

When they call the roll in the Senate, the Senators do not know whether to answer ‘Present’ or ‘Not guilty.’–Theodore Roosevelt.

It is essential that there should be organization of labor. This is an era of organization. Capital organizes and therefore labor must organize–Theodore Roosevelt.

Teddy, as he was affectionately known, wouldn’t be welcome in today’s Republican Party.  (Just take a look at the title of a book from a Fox New analyst).  Roosevelt’s legacy is busting monopolies, championing laws that favored the middle class and poor, and supporting Progressive politicians.  He broke the Gilded Age in half and we haven’t had a politician like him since.

I know for sure that two of my great-grandfathers voted for TR.  I once found an old article from my great-grandpa Fred Houghton.  He told the reporter for the Box Elder News Journal that showed the exuberance of my recently immigrated ancestor, “Today I went to the courthouse and became an American citizen.  Tomorrow, I plan on voting for Roosevelt!”

Utahns and Mormons loved Teddy Roosevelt.  It’s a long story and you can read more about it in this book or this article.  The short version is that Utah elected an Apostle named Reed Smoot to the American Senate in 1903.  The Senate put Smoot, along with the rest of the Church, on trial.  It lasted for many years until eventually Theodore Roosevelt intervened.  With the promise that Utah would “vote Republican” Smoot gained the crucial support he needed that would give Utah its most influential Progressive leader in the beginning of the 20th Century.

Unlike Hayes and other Gilded Age Presidents, Roosevelt took a risk on the Mormon people and they returned in kind, voting for Roosevelt and the Republican Party. Smoot went onto become a leader in the Senate and was no shrinking violet.  Senator Smoot was no Mike Lee or Brother Cliven Bundy either. When it came to land conservation, he defended many of the policies of Roosevelt for three decades.  According to the Utah State Division of History, here are a few things Senator Smoot helped do:

  • Gave the president and Forest Service power to protect forest lands,
  • Establish the National Park Service,
  • Create Zion and Bryce national parks,
  • Require people who profited from mining or generating electricity on public lands to pay a fee (called royalties) to the government.

(For more information on the politics of Reed Smoot, please check out this great article.)

How did a state and people that voted so overwhelmingly for Theodore Roosevelt, Reed Smoot, and other Progressive leaders, turn into a state that supports politicians like Mike Lee and Jason Chafetz?  It’s never made sense to me.  I think it’s fair to say that part of the reason why Utah is so Republican goes back to the promise that Joseph F. Smith made to Roosevelt.  But times have changed.  Recently, our schools have lagged.  Our environment has turned into a disaster.   Our state politicians have sold out to the lobbyists and billionaires.  It’s time we return to leaders who championed the causes and ideals of Roosevelt and Reed Smoot.

4 Responses to “My Great Grandpa Voted for Teddy Roosevelt”

  1. Parker
    May 15, 2014 at 10:49 pm #

    It is interesting to compare the church then, having an apostle in the Senate openly expressing and advocating progressive positions, with now where the leadership has chosen to remain largely silent (oblivious?) about political issues.

  2. Bill McBride
    May 17, 2014 at 6:15 am #

    I think the modern church membership’s loyalty to current Republicanism can be reduced to personal morality stances. As the Dems began to publicly abandon these moral positions, the members felt their only political home left was the GOP. And the GOP was more than willing to be the party of “family values”, as it sucked in so many other people of faith who would otherwise identify with a more progressive (or Christ-like) view.

  3. Margaret Cathey
    May 17, 2014 at 7:11 pm #

    Thanks for this information. I continue to fill in my knowledge gaps about the history of Mormons and politics. Good articles!!!!!
    The next step from this information is addressing how the LDS people became John Birch Society believers. IE-Skousen etc.
    I have seen this happen. What scares me the most is the charter schools here in Arizona and how many of them are teaching a completely false history of the Constitution to our young people- even my step grand kids.
    As a BYU Poli Sci BA and American history minor I know whats up and its hard to countermand the falsehoods when all the rest of the teachers and church members say I AM THE ONE WHO IS WRONG. When did the Church members become so uneducated and less open minded and unable to see reason or even to pursue research????? Sad state of affairs.

  4. Aaron Nelson
    May 17, 2014 at 11:03 pm #

    The evolution of the Church in the political arena can be very difficult to accept. From the beginning, the members of the Church were progressive in many ways. I certainly hope that things change from where we are now. I don’t think the hierarchy enjoys having a certain family in Nevada (the Bundy’s) parade around with BYU t-shirts on. In many ways, I wish the hierarchy were more free to express themselves on political issues because it would make a huge difference–as it has in the Catholic Church; however, in the past when the Church has become involved, it’s always led to problems. Here are two books that I have found very insightful on the subject:

    https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/399186.Mormonism_in_Transition?from_search=true

    and

    https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/373460.David_O_McKay_and_the_Rise_of_Modern_Mormonism?from_search=true

    These two books will give you more insight into politics within the Church.

Leave a Reply


eight × 9 =

Leave your opinion here. Please be nice. Your Email address will be kept private.